Don't agree at all, but let's leave it there. You obviously cannot be convinced based on plenty of previous to-and-fros on the subject on this and the other forum.
My opinion: an EGR valve was only installed for emissions regulation. An EGR without DPF is like a nipple on a male. And I have yet to see ANY service schedule that mentions "remove and clean EGR components".
A high pressure EGR is an unreliable, ugly piece if kit. Most engines use this type of EGR.